Question 1

Is Magikarp worth grading?

Accepted Answer

This is one of those cards where grading can genuinely pay off, but it's not a sure thing. Raw copies sit at $380, while a PSA 10 brings $3,933, which works out to roughly 10.3 times the ungraded price. That's a meaningful jump, and it's exactly why so many collectors send these in. The catch is that gem mint isn't guaranteed. Out of 25,791 total graded copies, only 4,216 came back PSA 10, so a good chunk of submissions land at Grade 9 or lower. Interestingly, Grade 9 copies have been trading at $12,518, which is well above the PSA 10 price right now, a reminder that grading markets can shift and don't always move the direction you'd expect. Factor in grading fees, turnaround time, and the very real chance your card doesn't come back gem, and grading becomes a calculated bet rather than a guaranteed win. If your copy is centered well with clean edges and no whitening, it's worth considering. If it's got visible wear, you might be better off holding it raw or selling as is.

Question 2

How rare is Magikarp?

Accepted Answer

With 25,791 copies graded so far, Magikarp isn't a rare card in the traditional sense, this illustration rare found its way into a lot of collections. But the PSA 10 population tells a different story. Only 4,216 of those graded copies earned a perfect grade, meaning gem mint condition is the real scarcity here, not the card itself. That gap between total population and gem mint population is what keeps PSA 10 prices well above raw, and it's worth remembering when you're deciding whether to grade your own copy or buy one already slabbed.

Question 3

Where can you pull Magikarp?

Accepted Answer

PackSpy tracks real pulls across pack sites like collector-crypt, packs, courtyard, and mnstr, and Magikarp has shown up 200 or more times across those platforms, with the biggest recorded pull landing at $822. That's not a guess or an estimate, it's actual pull data we've logged ourselves, which is something most price guides simply don't have. If you're chasing this one, it's been seen coming out of Water Pack, XY Evolutions, Pokemon Starter Pack, Pokemon Pro Pack, and Starter Pokemon Gacha Pack. Just keep in mind that opening packs is fundamentally a gamble, most rips don't come close to covering their cost, so treat any pull as a nice bonus rather than an expectation.

Question 4

How much is Magikarp worth?

Accepted Answer

A raw, ungraded Magikarp from Paldea Evolved is currently valued at $380. Graded copies climb from there, with PSA 10 gem mint copies worth $3,933 and Grade 9 copies actually trading higher at $12,518. The Magikarp price really depends on condition and whether it's been graded.

Question 5

Is Magikarp worth grading?

Accepted Answer

It can be. PSA 10 copies sell for about 10.3 times the raw price, which is a solid incentive. Just know that only 4,216 out of 25,791 graded copies have hit that perfect grade, so gem mint isn't guaranteed and grading always carries some risk and cost.

Question 6

What set is Magikarp from?

Accepted Answer

Magikarp #203 is from Paldea Evolved, released in 2023. It's an illustration rare illustrated by Shinji Kanda, which is part of why this particular Magikarp print has become such a favorite among collectors.

Grade	Value	Population	PSA / CGC
PSA 10 (Gem Mint)	$4.1k	4,224	3,933 / 291
PSA 9	$481	13,166	12,518 / 648
PSA 8	$367	6,867	6,315 / 552
PSA 7	$325	1,126	1,077 / 49
PSA 6	$302	301	284 / 17
PSA 5	$242	89	84 / 5
PSA 4	$206	52	50 / 2
PSA 3	$175	14	14 / -
PSA 2	$158	3	3 / -
PSA 1	$300	17	17 / -
Raw / Ungraded	$370	-	-

Magikarp #203 value & price

Related Magikarp & chase cards

Price history

Recent pulls of Magikarp

Chase Magikarp yourself

Magikarp price at every grade

Card details

Attacks

Where to pull Magikarp

The collector's take on Magikarp

Is Magikarp worth grading?

How rare is Magikarp?

Where can you pull Magikarp?

Questions people ask

Other Magikarp cards & values

More Paldea Evolved chase cards

Open a pack that holds Magikarp