Shining Magikarp 1st Edition Double Holo Error #66 value & price
Reviewed by Mumbles · Updated 8 Aug 2026Related Shining Magikarp & chase cards
Tap to open
Shining Magikarp is one of those cards that makes people stop scrolling through a Neo Revelation binder and look twice. It came out in 2001 as a Rare pull illustrated by Ken Sugimori, and this particular version, the 1st Edition Double Holo Error #66, is the kind of oddity that turns a fun fish card into a genuine collector's piece. If you are here trying to nail down Shining Magikarp value, the short answer is that raw copies are already trading well into the thousands, and that is before you even talk about grading.
Price history
InteractiveRaw value is $3.7k, up 0% over the past year, with an all-time high of $3.7k in December 2025.
Recent pulls of Shining Magikarp
Real pulls of this card across the tracked pack-opening sites, data no price guide has.
$840Ultra RarePokemon Expert PackTilt Rips · 19m ago
$39RarePokemon Dollar PackTilt Rips · 1h ago$60RarePokemon Expert PackTilt Rips · 3h ago
$42RawCelebrations PackPacks · 4h ago$39RarePokemon Starter PackTilt Rips · 5h ago
$42RawCelebrations PackPacks · 7h ago$42RawCelebrations PackPacks · 9h ago$840Ultra RarePokemon Expert PackTilt Rips · 9h ago
Chase Shining Magikarp yourself
Rip real, graded Pokémon packs live on the top pack-opening sites, the same ones PackSpy tracks. Our #1 pick right now is LastPack.
Affiliate links, we may earn a commission at no cost to you. Play responsibly. 18+.
Shining Magikarp price at every grade
Market value at each grade, with how many exist (population).
| Grade | Value | Population |
|---|---|---|
| PSA 10 (Gem Mint) | - | - |
| PSA 9 | $9.8k | - |
| PSA 8 | $7.9k | - |
| PSA 7 | $5.8k | - |
| PSA 6 | $4.3k | - |
| PSA 5 | $3.4k | - |
| PSA 4 | $2.9k | - |
| PSA 3 | $2.5k | - |
| PSA 2 | $2.2k | - |
| PSA 1 | - | - |
| Raw / Ungraded | $3.7k | - |
Prices & population from PriceCharting. Value shown is the PSA-grade market price; population is split by grading company.
Card details
- Card number
- 66 of 66
- Rarity
- Rare
- Type
- Water
- HP
- 30
- Stage
- Basic
- Weakness
- Lightning ×2
- Retreat cost
- 1
- Illustrator
- Ken Sugimori
- Released
- 2001
Attacks
- Gold ScaleWater
Your opponent may draw 2 cards. Either way, you may draw 2 cards.
- Dragon BondPsychic
Search your deck for a card named Gyarados, Dark Gyarados, or Shining Gyarados. Show it to your opponent and put it into your hand. Shuffle your deck afterward.
Where to pull Shining Magikarp
Rip real, graded Pokémon packs live on the top pack-opening sites, the same ones PackSpy tracks. Our #1 pick right now is LastPack.
Affiliate links, we may earn a commission at no cost to you. Play responsibly. 18+.
The collector's take on Shining Magikarp
Is Shining Magikarp worth grading?
So is it worth grading? Honestly, it depends on what you are chasing. A raw, ungraded copy sits at $3,700, and a Grade 9 jumps up to $9,850, which is a serious gap for just one grade point. That tells you buyers pay a real premium for a card that comes back clean. The catch is that PSA 10 pricing on this one is not established yet, so nobody can promise you a payout at gem mint, and older cards from 2001 often show print lines, whitening, or centering issues that keep them out of that top grade. Grading costs money and takes time, and there is no guarantee your copy comes back higher than it went in, so send it in because you believe in the card's condition, not because you are chasing a number that is not there yet.
How rare is Shining Magikarp?
Neo Revelation is a set from 2001, and anything carrying a 1st Edition stamp from that era was already printed in smaller numbers compared to later reprints. Add in the fact that this is a Double Holo Error, and you are looking at a card that was never meant to exist in quite this form, which is part of why collectors chase it so hard. We do not have exact population figures to share here, but between its Rare status, its age, and the error itself, this sits firmly in the harder-to-find tier of Neo Revelation cards, and that scarcity is a big part of why the price holds up the way it does.
Where can you pull Shining Magikarp?
This is where PackSpy actually earns its keep, because we track real pulls across pack sites rather than just quoting a price guide. Shining Magikarp has been pulled 96 times across tilt-rips, courtyard, mnstr, collector-crypt, and packs, with the biggest recorded pull value hitting $2,900. It has shown up in Pokemon Expert Pack, Pokémon Pro Pack, Pokemon Premium Pack, Pack 3, and Pokemon Starter Pack, so those are the products where collectors have actually landed it, not just where it is listed. Worth saying plainly, opening packs is a gamble and most rips do not come close to covering what you spent, so if you are ripping for this card specifically, go in with your eyes open and treat any hit as a bonus rather than the plan.
Questions people ask
How much is Shining Magikarp worth?+
A raw, ungraded Shining Magikarp is valued at $3,700, and a Grade 9 copy climbs to $9,850. PSA 10 pricing has not been established yet, so most of what you see quoted centers around raw and Grade 9 figures.
Is Shining Magikarp worth grading?+
It can be, given how much the price jumps from $3,700 raw to $9,850 at Grade 9. Just know that gem mint copies are tough to hit on older cards like this, PSA 10 value is not yet established, and grading always carries cost and risk, so weigh your copy's condition honestly before sending it in.
Why is the Shining Magikarp 1st Edition Double Holo Error #66 print worth more than the standard one?+
The 1st Edition stamp already marks it as an earlier, smaller print run from the 2001 Neo Revelation set, and the Double Holo Error makes it a genuine printing anomaly rather than a standard release. That combination of age, rarity, and error status is exactly what pushes collector demand and pricing above a normal copy.
Other Shining Magikarp cards & values
Every Shining Magikarp card we track, ranked by value.
More Neo Revelation chase cards
See all →
Mumbles built PackSpy so pack-opening data would not be a guessing game. We track real pulls and live card prices across the top pack sites and show what is actually happening, no hype, just the numbers. Every price and population figure here is pulled from live market data. More about Mumbles.
Open a pack that holds Shining Magikarp
Rip real, graded Pokémon packs live on the top pack-opening sites, the same ones PackSpy tracks. Our #1 pick right now is LastPack.
Affiliate links, we may earn a commission at no cost to you. Play responsibly. 18+.