Question 1

Is Magikarp worth grading?

Accepted Answer

Here's where it gets interesting. A raw, ungraded Magikarp sits at $2, but a PSA 10 in gem mint condition is worth 28.0x that, which puts the top grade at $53. A Grade 9 actually comes in even higher at $91 in the current market, which is a reminder that grading outcomes don't always move in a straight line and demand can shift between grades. So is it worth grading? If you've got a copy that looks sharp with clean edges and centering, sending it in could pay off, but grading costs money and time regardless of what comes back, and there's no guarantee you land a 10. For a card valued this modestly raw, it's worth doing the math on grading fees before you commit, since the upside is real but not enormous.

Question 2

How rare is Magikarp?

Accepted Answer

Across all grading services combined, there are 430 graded copies of this Magikarp on record, and only 98 of those have earned a PSA 10. That means gem mint copies make up a minority of what's already a fairly small graded population. It's not an ultra rare card by any means, but hitting that top grade clearly isn't easy, and that scarcity at the very top is a big part of why PSA 10 pricing sits where it does relative to the raw card.

Question 3

Where can you pull Magikarp?

Accepted Answer

This is where PackSpy's own data comes in handy, since we track real pulls across pack sites rather than relying on price guides alone. Magikarp has been pulled 200 or more times across platforms like tilt-rips, packs, collector-crypt, courtyard and mnstr, and the biggest recorded pull value on this card hit $4,300, which shows just how much variance there can be depending on what grade or version someone lands. It's shown up in packs like the Pokemon Dime Pack, XY Evolutions, Elite Pokémon Gacha Pack, Wildcard Basic Pack and Celestial Pokémon Gacha Pack. Worth saying plainly: opening packs is gambling, and most rips don't come close to that $4,300 outlier, so treat any pack purchase as entertainment first and a possible bonus second.

Question 4

How much is Magikarp worth?

Accepted Answer

A raw, ungraded Magikarp is worth about $2 right now, which makes it an easy card to pick up for a collection. Its value climbs a lot once it's graded, especially at the higher grades, so how much is Magikarp worth really depends on its condition and whether it's been through grading.

Question 5

Is Magikarp worth grading?

Accepted Answer

It can be, since a PSA 10 is worth 28.0x the raw price, but grading isn't free and gem mint copies aren't guaranteed. With only 98 PSA 10s existing out of 430 total graded copies, hitting that top grade takes a genuinely clean card, so check your copy closely before sending it in.

Question 6

How much is a PSA 10 Magikarp worth?

Accepted Answer

A PSA 10 Magikarp is currently valued at $53, a solid jump from the $2 raw price. Interestingly, a Grade 9 copy is valued even higher at $91, so it's worth checking current demand for both grades rather than assuming higher grade always means higher price.

Grade	Value	Population	PSA / CGC
PSA 10 (Gem Mint)	$210	99	53 / 46
PSA 9	$52	146	91 / 55
PSA 8	$21	112	38 / 74
PSA 7	$15	55	25 / 30
PSA 6	$12	14	8 / 6
PSA 5	$10	12	6 / 6
PSA 4	$9.99	4	1 / 3
PSA 3	$8.00	2	1 / 1
PSA 2	$7.00	2	2 / -
PSA 1	-	-	- / -
Raw / Ungraded	$2.04	-	-

Magikarp #50 value & price

Related Magikarp & chase cards

Price history

Recent pulls of Magikarp

Chase Magikarp yourself

Magikarp price at every grade

Card details

Attacks

Where to pull Magikarp

The collector's take on Magikarp

Is Magikarp worth grading?

How rare is Magikarp?

Where can you pull Magikarp?

Questions people ask

Other Magikarp cards & values

More Base Set 2 chase cards

Open a pack that holds Magikarp