Question 1

Is Magikarp worth grading?

Accepted Answer

So is it worth grading? Here's the honest answer: a PSA 10 Magikarp is worth 11.0 times what the raw card sells for, jumping from $53 raw to $580 graded gem mint, with a Grade 9 landing at $87. That's a real gap, and it's the kind of jump that gets collectors excited. But gem mint is called gem mint for a reason, it's not easy to hit, and centering, edge wear, or a stray print line can knock a card down a grade fast. Add in grading fees and turnaround time, and you're taking on real risk for a shot at that top price. If you've got a copy that looks clean under a light, it can be worth the gamble, but go in with your eyes open rather than assuming every submission comes back a 10.

Question 2

How rare is Magikarp?

Accepted Answer

As a Common in the Generations set, Magikarp wasn't printed with the kind of scarcity that drives up short-term hype, and that's part of why the raw price sits where it does. The real scarcity conversation here is about condition, not print numbers: Commons get handled, sleeved late, tossed in binders, and that means truly pristine copies are rarer in practice than you'd expect just from the rarity tier alone. That's exactly why the PSA 10 price sits so far above the raw and Grade 9 figures, gem mint condition is the scarce part of this equation, not the card itself.

Question 3

Where can you pull Magikarp?

Accepted Answer

This is where PackSpy's data actually earns its keep, because we track real pulls across pack sites, not just guide prices. Magikarp has been pulled 200 or more times across packs, collector-crypt, tilt-rips, mnstr, and courtyard, and we've seen it show up in XY Evolutions, Starter Pokémon Gacha Pack, Elite Pokémon Gacha Pack, Pokemon Dime Pack, and Pack 5. The biggest recorded pull value we've logged for this card is $4,300, which tells you that even a Common Magikarp can land in a hot pack under the right circumstances. Worth saying plainly: opening packs is a gamble and most rips don't beat what you paid, so treat any pull as a bonus, not a plan.

Question 4

How much is Magikarp worth?

Accepted Answer

A raw, ungraded Magikarp from the Generations Toys R Us #22 print currently sits at $53. That's the baseline most collectors reference when asking about Magikarp price, before grading changes the picture.

Question 5

Is Magikarp worth grading?

Accepted Answer

It can be, since a PSA 10 sells for 11.0 times the raw price, taking it from $53 up to $580. Just know that gem mint is genuinely hard to achieve on a well handled Common, so factor in grading costs and the real chance of landing a Grade 9 at $87 instead.

Question 6

How much is a PSA 10 Magikarp worth?

Accepted Answer

A PSA 10 Magikarp is valued at $580, which is 11.0 times the raw card's $53 price. That gap is what makes grading tempting, but it also reflects how tough gem mint condition is to actually pull off.

Grade	Value	Population	PSA / CGC
PSA 10 (Gem Mint)	$966	51	37 / 14
PSA 9	$84	402	327 / 75
PSA 8	$57	445	302 / 143
PSA 7	$42	118	95 / 23
PSA 6	$27	67	61 / 6
PSA 5	$17	36	33 / 3
PSA 4	$16	4	4 / -
PSA 3	$13	2	1 / 1
PSA 2	$12	2	2 / -
PSA 1	$80	3	3 / -
Raw / Ungraded	$60	-	-

Magikarp Toys R Us #22 value & price

Related Magikarp & chase cards

Price history

Recent pulls of Magikarp

Chase Magikarp yourself

Magikarp price at every grade

Card details

Attacks

Where to pull Magikarp

The collector's take on Magikarp

Is Magikarp worth grading?

How rare is Magikarp?

Where can you pull Magikarp?

Questions people ask

Other Magikarp cards & values

More Generations chase cards

Open a pack that holds Magikarp